Analysis and Ranking of Top 8 American Idol Women
|
Written by: NewsToob | Mar 05, 2008 | 0 comments |
|

If you tuned in for the final eight ladies on “American Idol,” you witnessed a mediocre show. Overall, the ladies were pretty weak, but there were four women that really stood out — and you can find them in the top four positions on my list down there at the bottom. Were the ladies better than the guy’s performances last night? It’s a toss up!
Asia’h Epperson – She performed Whitney Houston’s “I Wanna Dance with Somebody” and the house was dancing with her! Simon says, “Final six!” All I can say regarding her clothes, “4 out of 10.” U. G. L. Y.
Kady Malloy – Kady looked like a Jessica Alba-ish shooting star, but she did not sound like one. Her notes had the dogs barking outside of my railroad car!
Amanda Overmyer – She performed in her original rocker-chick style and hammered this one out of the park! Amanda is going to stay around and make things interesting.
Ramiele Malubay – Uh, no! Paula said, “She deserves to be in the final six.” I say “bottom six.”
Carly Smithson – It was a good solid performance. Paula congratulated her by saying, “You’re like a dependable dog.” By the way, do not piss Paula off.
Kristy Lee Cook – She performed with a mild country twist and it was just OK. Nothing to write home about here – especially if she leaves tonight.
Brooke White – She kept it simple with a little acoustic guitar and a lack of back up singers on “Love is a Battlefield.” And yes, there is a battlefield because she IS in this to win it! Real cool! Simon says, “Two weeks running you’ve given a great performance.”
Syesha Mercado – Another strong performance from Syesha. It wasn’t the best of the night, but it was in the top half.
Tags:They say you’re only as good as your last performance, so here is my ranking of the ladies based on last night’s performances:
- Amanda Overmyer
- Brooke White
- Syesha Mercado
- Carly Smithson
- Asia’h Epperson
- Kristy Lee Cook
- Ramiele Malubay
- Kady Malloy






















